Skip To Content

10 Fish Bay Real Estate Listings

Updated 78 minutes ago
$650,000
1 of 10
Fish Bay | St John
0.84 acres
On Site: 35 Days
© 2026 St. John Board of Realtors.
$99,000
1 of 5
Fish Bay | St John
0.62 acres
On Site: 37 Days
© 2026 St. John Board of Realtors.
$169,000
1 of 14
Fish Bay | St John
0.65 acres
On Site: 66 Days
© 2026 St. John Board of Realtors.
$2,390,000
1 of 36
Fish Bay | St John
2 beds
1 ½ baths
4,510 sqft
On Site: 130 Days
© 2026 St. John Board of Realtors.
$160,000
1 of 6
Fish Bay | St John
0.67 acres
On Site: 136 Days
© 2026 St. John Board of Realtors.
$4,500,000
1 of 12
Fish Bay | St John
6 beds
5 baths
4,380 sqft
On Site: 171 Days
© 2026 St. John Board of Realtors.
$275,000
1 of 6
Fish Bay | St John
0.61 acres
On Site: 172 Days
© 2026 St. John Board of Realtors.
$145,000
1 of 10
Fish Bay | St John
0.32 acres
On Site: 400 Days
© 2026 St. John Board of Realtors.
$2,349,000
1 of 43
Fish Bay | St John
3 beds
3 baths
1 ½ baths
4,268 sqft
On Site: 441 Days
© 2026 St. John Board of Realtors.
$250,000
1 of 7
Fish Bay | St John
0.74 acres
On Site: 479 Days
© 2026 St. John Board of Realtors.